Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Thomas H. Greco, Jr.'s avatar

Brett, this is the best debunking of Bitcoin and similar artificial digital commodities I've ever seen.

Bravo!

The real Dollar-Killah requires reclaiming the "credit commons," i.e. community control of credit that producers and sellers of real value allocate to one another, along with denomination of that credit in units based on a real commodity or group of commodities. My recent presentation at the RAMICS Conference in Rome described how that can be done. I'll be posting it soon on my website beyondmoney.net and on my Substack channel.

Expand full comment
Parsifal Solomon's avatar

Thanks, I wasn't quite sure where it was going - got a bit lost in the abbreviations maybe, but then it became very clear. And what a great analogy, something in the tone of the whole crypto business is really well represented by the atmosphere of wrestling (if you ever go to Mexico City I highly recommend the wrestling there, it felt like a much purer, more essential, and somehow more honest expression of the same kind of show.) A couple of thoughts arising:

1. Maybe better to call them pseudocurrencies?

2. Is there not also an inkling, somewhere in the background of our relationships with the standard monetary system monster, of a similar sense of 'taking part in a performance?' Even if we know that the value of the money we use comes into being through a vastly complex multilayered web of influences, there is also a sense that some of the influences behind that value are also somewhat arbitrary - and some people and groups of people have far more power in determining it than we as ordinary users do. The extent of that power is I'm sure debatable, and certainly one I have very little knowledge about.

So even if it's just a story, that a few people have the power to change it, whereas we are chained to the heavy immobility of its complexity, then perhaps what crypto is selling, with the story of 'money being just numbers', is that you too can see the truth behind the creation of value... and that will liberate you.

Though whether buying into crypto could ever give you any similar power - to also make up those numbers without any influence from people of undesirable motive or association - is also highly questionable.

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts